Review: Iron Man: Extremis Part 5

| | Comments (1)

Iron Man - Extremis part 5, Written by Warren Ellis, Illustrated by Adi Granov

So here we are at issue 5. I have mixed feelings about how things turned out.

In all fairness, this is not a bad story. It's not in the realm of Identity Crisis (the best-written bad comic of 2004). If they filmed a movie off of this, I'd be in line opening day. Yes, if they filmed a movie off of any script, I'd be in line opening day, but the point remains. The book does not have bad art. If they used the art as production art for a movie. . .OK, I'd wonder if the projector bulb needed changing, but it's still excellent, if it's not vibrant.

We also get Ellis' take on Iron Man's origins, and Granov's take on the first Iron Man Armor and it's not bad. In fact, I can almost forgive all the parts I didn't like about issue five just for the line "Say hello to the Iron Man, you terrorist scum." Almost. It's just, after much mulling it over, I don't like the idea of Stark rewiring his own brain.

Short synopsis of the issue: While Stark's body undergoes repairs via the Extremis process, he flashes back to a slightly updated origin story of Iron Man. The story is the same one we've come to know and love, only with nameless terrorists in place of communist guerillas. Oddly, we do not see what happens to Dr. Yinsen in this issue (but perhaps in issue six). Stark emerges from the Extremis cocoon and reveals to Dr. Maya Hensen that he tweaked the Extremis before injection. He now has the suit's under-sheath stored inside his body and wired into his brain. As Tony puts it "I control the Iron Man with thought, like it was another limb." After further unnerving Maya by dialing her cell-phone without moving his mouth (presumably by relaying through the nearby armor), he dons a new Iron Man armor and sets out after the Extremis augmented terrorist.

Now, I could go on a small fan-boy rant here that the armor has had a thought control system for ages and doesn't Ellis bother to avail himself of the archives, and bleh blah blech, but really 1) that serves no one and 2) it's probably already been done somewhere else already with more fire, invective, and total perspective loss than I can muster at this hour.

My problem is I'm at best ambivalent about Tony Stark, brilliant inventor and cyborg, as opposed to the more traditional Tony Stark, brilliant inventor. Logically, it's not that huge of a departure, Stark has already gone through one or two bionic hearts. He's rewired/replaced his peripheral nervous system at least once when he faked his own death after being paralyzed. That didn't bug me as much at the time, but that's because I was much more annoyed with the contrived falling out between Tony and Jim Rhodes that went with that plot. I still wasn't thrilled about it.

You could make the case that this is nothing more than an improved interface with the armor. The nerve pickups now reside inside the operator instead of on the inner surface of the armor, and if that's as far as it went, I don't think I'd be as bothered, but when Tony says "I can see through satellites now" I don't think he's exaggerating and I don't like the implications.

To me Iron Man has always been the clever guy in the room full of demi-gods. He's an affirmation that wits, determination, and ingenuity can level the playing field with adamantium claws, radioactive spiders and magic hammers. But in Extremis, that's no longer sufficient. Now you need your own set of trans-human capabilities if you're going to set foot on the playing field, or you're going to get creamed and that just doesn't feel like an Iron Man story to me.

1 Comments

Just remember the mantra that can get you through any poor writing/editorial decision (Spider-Man replaced by a clone, Green Lantern going crazy, New Avengers): This too shall pass.

I ignore the cover logos--as far as I'm concerned, Joe Casey is writing the regular Iron Man series.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Wombat published on January 30, 2006 12:10 AM.

Review: Iron Man: Extremis Part 4 was the previous entry in this blog.

Noted in passing: F-14 Tomcat to retire from service is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.